This Lemon Honey Swiss Roll is a sweet and bright dessert with a stunning decorative outside and a creamy and smooth filling.
I told myself I wouldn’t do this again, but here we are… Once a challenge gets stuck in my head, it is quite hard to get it out. I am going to bake my way through season sixteen of the Great British Bake Off. I’m so scared.
Week one has always been cake week. And that’s where I am going to start. The first challenge is a Swiss Roll. Easy enough, right? I rewatched the episode to get some inspiration and realized all the bakers were doing the same decorating style: embedding a design into the cake.
That upped the challenge, I would say. I have never done something like this before, and I was quite nervous to try it. My fear of failure kept me out of the kitchen for longer than I would like to admit. But when I got off the couch, I was finally able to bake, and here’s the result: a Honey Lemon Swiss Roll
Check out the Make section of MCG for a variety of fun recipes, including delightful desserts and savory dishes that will tantalize your taste buds.
I debated a lot about which ingredients to use. There are some classic baking ingredients needed, but I also started to think about the variation of these ingredients. I decided to use vanilla paste over extract to lend that extra flavor. I also had a major debate about using all-purpose flour or cake flour. A Swiss roll needs to be light and fluffy to offset the naturally dense tendency a roll has. Cake flour lends itself well.
I ended up using quite a range of ingredients, including: powdered sugar, butter, eggs, all-purpose flour, cake flour, sugar, whole milk, vanilla paste, lemon extract, salt, baking powder, lemons, heavy whipping cream, and honey. Fourteen ingredients – with some doing double duty by being included in multiple components.
Process
The Lemon Sponge Batter
I decided to make the design out of the batter instead of using a different mix. It just felt like it would make sense. Since that was the case, I ended up making the batch a 1 ½ batch instead (the recipe was adjusted to the higher amount). The method felt very familiar to a standard cake. I did end up doing this recipe twice, and the first time, the cake felt like it didn’t have enough lift. For the second time, I added a bit of vegetable shortening to help give some structure.
I started by beating the vegetable shortening, eggs, vanilla paste, lemon, and sugar in a large bowl. I wanted the mixture to really whip up and gain some air (which feels like an oxymoron since gaining air means getting… nothing. Well, nothing visible).
In a separate bowl, I sifted together the cake flour, baking powder, and salt. This is a cake I will advocate for using the sifting method. The lemon honey Swiss roll really wants to be light, and I’m using quite a few methods to get there. With my two mixtures together, it was time to fold.
Adding the flour in batches helps control the batter and keep my arm from being a total wreck. I started by adding one-third of the flour mixture to the eggs. The flour needed to disappear completely before I felt okay adding more. Using the folding method seemed the most apt for this process. It helps keep it in the air. Once the flour was fully incorporated, I folded in the milk and lemon zest as well.
Making the Design
I originally was thinking of having only black for the design to keep it a simple outline. But that felt a little… too simple. In the end, I went with black, yellow, and green for the colors on the lemon honey Swiss roll.
Since this is a lemon honey Swiss roll, I feel like bees just naturally fall into the design. Is it cliché? Yes. But I like it, and that’s what matters. The black did come into play for the bees to create the outlines. It’s hard to create an outline on something that is somewhat difficult to see. So, the black outline makes it a bit easier.
And filling it with yellow in particular places really brought out the bees. I also added a few yellow dots to help add color as “background” bees. The next component of the design is the hex background. I wanted the background to look like a beehive, so I decided to go with a hexagonal pattern. I probably should have gotten a stencil, but I decided to just freehand it. My confidence randomly rises for the strangest things. And it turned out visible but not so consistent.
The last part of the design was adding some green. I felt the yellow and black were just a little too stark. I think adding some green leaves really elevated the design. There were definitely some messes, though. I used a toothpick to clean up as much as I could. Then it was time for the design to chill.
Baking and Rolling
As the design finished chilling, it was time to add the cake layer. I tried to add the layer in a slow and methodical manner to get full and even coverage. Also to ensure I didn’t smudge the design. Once the batter was set in place, it was time to go to the oven.
This is a cake where the window between underdone, perfect, and overdone is very short. But I did have one thing to prep while the sponge was in the oven. I placed out a sheet of silicone and gave it a dusting of powdered sugar.
When the sponge came out of the oven, I let it rest for about 1 minute before turning it out onto a parchment sheet. I flipped it once again to have the design in the proper position. Then I placed my hands along the shorter edge and rolled it up. The longer side is better for the roll as it gives a better swirl. And it immediately showed signs of cracking….
Normally, rolling the sponge while hot helps to avoid cracking later. But that’s only if you get the bake right. One of the most notorious things about Swiss roll-type cakes is overbaking. Overbaking leads to cracking, which is where I found myself. But, in the spirit of the challenge, I continued ahead.
The Lemon honey filling
The next component to make was the lemon and honey filling. After all, I needed to add the honey somewhere, otherwise it wouldn’t be a lemon honey Swiss roll. For this filling, I started working over the stove. First, I set up some gelatin to bloom.
I then added lemon juice, honey, vanilla paste, and salt to a small saucepan. My main goal was to create a syrup-like mixture that has one consistency. I tried to keep the mixture on a medium to low heat to prevent the honey from caramelizing. It has happened before. I do not want it to happen again (unless it’s on purpose).
I removed the mixture from the heat and added it to the gelatin. A few stirs got the gelatin to fully dissolve. Then I set aside the mixture to cool. I was aiming for the syrup to be about 80 degrees Fahrenheit when I needed it next. In a large mixing bowl, I whisked up a cup of heavy whipped cream to make a very full amount of whipped cream. The result was light and fluffy.
With the cream whipped and the syrup cooled, I folded the syrup into the cream to create a mousse-like filling. And now that all the components were complete, it was time for assembly.
Assembly
I started by unrolling the sponge. Slow movements seemed like the best approach to help coax the roll into being malleable while also being set into a roll. With the sponge unrolled, I spread the filling across the non-decorated side as evenly as possible. I also tried to keep an ½ inch border around the sponge just to help the filling have somewhere to go.
Then comes the nerve-wracking task of rolling the sponge back up. I was nervous about so many things; will the sponge crack? Am I going to crush the filling? Am I going to see that classic swirl? But I managed to make a pretty good lemon honey Swiss roll.
Reflections
This experiment turned into a little more of a mess than I was hoping for, but a delicious result. I was able to get the hint of a swirl, but not the swirl that I really wanted. I think I was a little too gentle when rolling for fear of squishing out the filling… And then there is also the cracking. I had worried that the cake was too pale and left it in the oven. It was probably ready to go. Looking back, I should have done a more thorough check.
But the flavor turned out amazing! I really like the sweetness of the cake combined with the tartness of the lemon. And the honey was somehow sweet and bitter at the same time. It created a complex and rich flavor that I really enjoyed.
Lessons
My Freezer is Too Small
I realized that I could not fit the baking sheet in my freezer. It’s just too small to accommodate that. And freezing baking components has always been a bit of a challenge. But then I remembered; it’s cold outside! I ended up placing the tray in the garage as it was cold but also enclosed and safe. There are many ways to get around certain challenges and using nature is always a favor of mine.
Recipe
Honey Lemon Swiss Roll
Ingredients
Lemon Sponge
- 6 Eggs
- 3/4 Cup Sugar
- 3 Tablespoons Whole Milk
- 1 Teaspoon Vanilla Paste
- Lemon extract check this
- ½ Teaspoon Salt
- 1 Teaspoon Baking Powder
- 1 ½ Cup Baking Flour or all-purpose
- 1 Lemon zested
- ¾ Cup Vegetable Shortening
- Powdered Sugar for dusting
Lemon / Honey Filling
- ¾ Cup Whole Milk
- 4 Tablespoon Lemon Juice
- ½ Cup Honey
- 5 Tablespoon All-Purpose Flour
- ¼ Cup Vegetable Shortening
- ½ Cup Heavy Whipping Cream
- ¾ Teaspoon Vanilla Paste
- ¼ Teaspoon Salt
Instructions
Lemon Sponge
- In a large bowl, beat the eggs, vanilla paste, lemon extract, and sugar, until light and fluffy (should triple in volume).
- In a separate large bowl, sift together flour, baking powder, and salt.
- Take 1/3rd of the flour mixture and gently mix into the egg mixture. Repeat two more times (until flour mixture is fully incorporated). If the
- Fold in milk and lemon zest.
- Split the mixture into however many colors your design has. Add the food color and mix until the dye is fully incorporated. Repeat for any other food colors.
- Using a piping bag, pipe your pattern onto a lined baking tray (line with parchment paper of silicone mat).
- Place the baking tray in the freezer. Let it freeze for 20 minutes.
- Remove the baking tray from the freezer. Spread the batter evenly on the baking tray on top of the design. Bake for 10 – 12 minutes (the window for a good bake is short so this is one you will want to keep your eye on).
- Dust a piece of parchment paper or silicone. Turn the warm cake onto the dusted piece and peel off the original parchment paper / silicone mat very gently.
- Take the shorter edge and roll the cake (with the paper inside) along the longer side. Let it cool.
Lemon / Honey Filling
- In a medium saucepan, over medium heat, whisk together the flour and milk and cook until thickened.
- Add lemon juice, honey, vanilla and salt. Reduce the heat to medium-low. Whisk until fully combined. Remove from heat and transfer to another bowl. Let cool to about 70 – 80 degrees Fahrenheit, stirring occasionally to prevent skin from forming.
- In a large mixing bowl, whisk the heavy whipping cream until light and fluffy. Add a portion of the lemon / honey paste into the whipping cream and fold until incorporated. Repeat until the two are completely combined.
Assembly
- Gently unroll the sponge leaving it on the parchment paper / silicone mat.
- Spread the filling over the sponge as evenly as possible leave ½ inch around each of the edges. Slowly roll the cake, removing the parchment paper.
- The roll can be served immediately or wrapped in cling wrap and stored in the fridge (minimum an hour) for easier slicing.

Leave a ReplyCancel reply